Castro's
economic policy, up to 1972, passed through no less than four different
phases. The initial period ( 1959 - 1963 ) saw rapid agricultural reform
that began with the establishment os the Instituo Nacional de Reforma
Agraria ( INRA ). One of its primary functions was to carry out the
First Agrarian Reform Law, which was passed in May 1959. According to
its provisions, properties in excess of 402.3 hectares were proscribed;
the upper limit for especially productive land was raised to 1342 hectares;
large estates were to be worked as co-operatives; anyone cultivating
up to 67 hectares was given ownership of that land and a minimum of
27 hectares was given to those who were already working on the land.
( Mac Ewan, 1981 ). The seizure of American owned ranches would have
bitter recriminations, which would be reflected in the Cuban Liberty
and Solidarity Act of March 1996. The initial step of Castro's economic
policy involved a wider concentration on agriculture for which there
were two main reasons; the first was practical : sugar was the only
viable means of foreign exchange needed to purchase machinery, fuel
and other elements which were necessary components of economic modernization.
Furthermore, Cuba's main lifeblood was sugar, and it was for this commodity
that the U.S.S.R. was willing to enter into long-term agreements regarding
its purchase. In February 1960, Soviet Deputy Premier, Anastas Mikoyan,
concluded the first trade agreement by which the U.S.S.R. would buy
425.000 tons of Cuban sugar in 1960; they would purchase one million
tons annually for the next four years while granting the Cuban government
$ 100 million in "long-term credits and technical assistance."
{Gonzales ( 1974) .
The U.S. then
cut Cuba's sugar quota, thus exposing the island's economy to potential
ruin. Castro then responded by nationalizing all ranches and factories
previously operated by U.S. companies. In January 1961, outgoing U.S.
President, Dwight D. Eisenhower, severed all diplomatic relations with
Cuba. An economic embargo was imposed later that year.
The second economic phase occurred from 1963 to 1965 and involved a combined
reliance on sugar, but with a greater concentration on industrialization,
in the hope of breaking this reliance.
The second Agrarian Reform Law (1963 ) expropriated the lands of those
holding more than 67 acres. These, in turn, were consolidated into state
owned farms which also replaced co-operatives. By this time, the state
now held 76% of total land and 63% of cultivated land. In the shift away
from agricultural to the non-agricultural and industrial spheres, total
investment in agriculture fell from 29.2% of total expenditure to 24.3%
from 1962- 63. Meanwhile, investment in industry rose from 23.1% to 31.6%.
This relatively brief period saw a greater concentration on developing
other social sciences such as housing, education, transportation and communication.
As such, this period saw the reduction of cane acreage to make way for
new crops and the erection of several new factories.
The attempt
at industrialization brought many problems. Its eventual failure was rooted
in the general lack of raw materials and other resources, as well as the
huge import bill from the U.S.S.R. It was on the basis of these facts
that Castro decided to put industrialization on hold, while re-shifting
the focus on increasing sugar production and developing and diversifying
the agrarian sector. In summary: this "Agro-industrial" strategy
saw a relocation of resources to the countryside, a shift in emphasis
away from industrial and urban centres and a heavy investment on agriculture
by the late 1960's, with a corresponding dip in expenditure on social
resources such as housing and education.
The agricultural drive was to culminate in the goal of the 10 million
ton sugar harvest scheduled for 1970. An impossible venture, it nonetheless
captivated national attention as everything was concentrated on realizing
this goal.
In 1966,
investment in agriculture rose to 40.4% as compared to spending on industry
which fell to 16.7% of total expenditure that year. The demand for labour
required by the sugar industry, led to a huge labour-mobilization programme
that involved workers from other sectors voluntarily leaving their jobs
to work in the cane fields.
Students from secondary schools and colleges ( 160.000 by 1968 ) were
also encouraged to lend a hand. Also, women were organized through the
committees for the Defence of the Revolution ( C.D.A.'s ). In the end,
the drive, predictably, failed. The harvest ( while still a record crop
) amounted to only 8.5 million tons. The failure of this, as well as other
economic goals - citrus fruit (only 46.000 out of 100.000 hectares was
under cultivation), - rice, coffee, tobacco and milk production - had
an extensive impact. Apart from the immense financial losses, there were
disruptions in other economic sectors due to the large concentration on
agrarian reform. On the plus side the general status of the economy did
actually improve.The GMP ( gross material product ) grew by 20% between
1969 and 1970, while industry ( including sugar ) rose by 25%.
The decade
of the 1970's witnessed a general economic expansion. Among the economic
reforms was a greater concentration on providing material incentives to
workers; the decentralization of production units into smaller components;
concentration on promoting growth within the livestock sector and an overall
commitment towards greater technical efficiency. Such reforms made possible
the expansion of education with the construction of 300 boarding type
secondary schools in the countryside between 1971 and '75. In the meantime
Cuba strengthened its economic ties with the East Bloc. In 1972 it signed
a series of pacts with the U.S.S.R. in the areas of financial aid, trade
and deferment of Cuban debt payments. In addition, Cuba became a member
of the Council for Mutual Economic Assistance (COMECON). By the end of
the decade 40% of Cuban foreign trade was being conducted with capitalist
countries.
However,
Cuba was to be hit by severe problems during the 1980's. In 1985 a drop
in oil prices cut hard currency profits earned by Cuba from the re-export
of Soviet supplied oil saved through conservation methods. During the
previous two years, the country re-exported 2-3 million tons out of the
12 million tons it received, generating 40% of its total hard currency
earnings. The Cuban economic strategy of combining sugar cultivation with
attempts to build modern industries, required large amounts of exports
which contributed to an increase in its hard currency debt from $ 2.8
billion
(1983) to $ 6.1 billion (1987). In 1986 Cuba tried to negotiate debt payments
with the Club of Paris : it proved unsuccessful. " The drop in Cuba's
credit worthiness made it extremely difficult for Havana to obtain additional
loans". ( Gunn, 1993). Despite this, by the late 1980's, the socialist
world purchased 63% of Cuban sugar, 73% of the nickel, 95% of the citrus
and 100% of electronic goods.
COMECON states
in turn provided Cuba with 63% of its food, 80% of its non fuel material
food imports, 96% of its fuel, 80% of its machinery and 74% of manufactured
goods.
From these facts, it is not hard to imagine the extent of damage done
to the Cuban economy when the communist regimes in Eastern Europe started
to fall, and the Soviet Union finally collapsed in 1991. By 1989-90, conditions
were already so bad, that Castro announced that the island had entered
a "special period in the Time of Peace". Under this "plan",
a series of austerity measures, originally designed to be enacted during
economic isolation, were implemented in the hope of adapting the economy
to the new conditions and reinserting it into the world market. By 1991
these adjustments involved the slashing of imports - including foodstuffs,
fuel and spare parts - as well as an increase in rationing.
SOCIAL
POLICY/SOCIAL IMPACT
Among the
original intentions of the Castro Government was the improvement in the
social welfare of the people of the island. This was first evidenced in
the sphere of housing. Upon ascension to power in 1959, the new administration
immediately reduced private rents (50%) and mortgage rates. Rents were
totally abolished in 1960 and within the next 20 years the government
financed the construction of several apartment complexes in and around
Havana. These included the giant Alamar complex, to the east of the capital,
which housed 25.000 factory workers by 1976.
The Castro
Government's commitment to education has also served many benefits to
Cuban society. During the 1940's and 1950's the illiteracy rate stood
at 40%. Schooling was mainly confined to children of upper class backgrounds,
while teaching appointments were made on the basis of one's own political
leanings. Furthermore, the privilege of education was limited to the major
urban centres and only extended into rural areas in a few instances. Public
schools were poorly maintained, lacking even some of the most basic materials,
such as books. Under Castro many major reforms were instituted. Volunteer
teachers were sent out into many rural districts and parochial schools
were nationalized. Such moves sought to bring education to large masses
who had previously been denied access to this institution. According to
Castro: "Without education it is impossible to increase the productivity
of our people, without education it is impossible to become a highly industrial
country; without education it is impossible to organize the people and
the country on higher levels". (Castro on august 16, 1961, Education
in Revolution p.23).Thus, education was viewed as an instrumental component
in the general plan to reform the Cuban economy and general society as
a whole. In this spirit, 10.000 new classrooms were built in rural districts
in the late 1960's and travelling libraries were introduced.
The 1970's
saw the construction of huge, modern secondary schools in the countryside
where students, apart from receiving orthodox teaching in the classroom,
also worked in nearby agricultural fields in a move designed to foster
revolutionary spirit.Reform was also made at the tertiary educational
level. In the late 1980's, 939.900 students attended primary schools,
775.350 attended secondary schools, 262.200 were in other institutions
of higher learning, the largest of which was the University of Havana
(1728). By 1992, the literacy rate had risen to 99% and 92% of those between
the ages of 6 - 14 attended school.
Among other
social amenities provided by the Castro government were improvements in
health care. In 1959 the government combined more than 50 different health
care plans, begun by previous regimes, into a single system. Under this
plan, new hospitals were erected and many new doctors were produced by
the education system. By the 1980's Cuba had 58.700 hospital beds and
28.100 physicians. Also, the outset of the Castro era saw the erection
of "people's stores" where goods, including foodstuffs, were
made available to the general public. The Castro government also sought
to improve life in the area of social relations; racial discrimination
was outlawed and gender equality was promoted. Despite these general improvements,
it is necessary to mention that some major discrepancies had appeared
in Castro's social milieu, long before the collapse of the Soviet Union.
Moral, rather than material incentives hindered worker enthusiasm and
by the 1970's shortages of many items meant that strict rationing ( involving
long lines ) were already commonplace.
INTERNATIONAL
POLICY/INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS
From 1960
to 1991, Cuba found itself heavily entrenched in the Cold War. Castro's
socialist policies (especially the nationalization of American owned
companies) and his affinity towards the Soviet Union, served to weaken
Cuba-United States relations. American opposition to the Castro movement
has been highlighted by the Economic Embargo imposed on Cuba in early
1961.The
purpose of this embargo was to make Cuba's economic dependence on the
U.S.S.R. more costly, while, at the same time, reducing Cuba's showcase
appeal to other countries in the region. In April of that year the U.S.
backed an invasion force - composed primarily of Cuban-American exiles
that trained in Central America. In 1954, the U.S. had supported a similar
operation that eventually led to the overthrow of President Jacomo Arbenz.
The impression at that time was that Castro was unpopular within Cuba,
and that such a movement would eventually garner public support along
the way. However, Castro was, ultimately, tipped off about the planned
operation and his forces were able to intercept and defeat the invasion
force at the Bay of Pigs. In August 1962, another crisis developed when
aerial photographs revealed the presence of Soviet missile installations
on Cuba. U.S. President, John F. Kennedy, ordered a naval blockage of
the island until the missiles were removed. Unknown at the time, the
United States had its own Jupiter missiles in Turkey, directed at Russian
territory. Eventually, a secret trade-off led to the removal of the
weapons from both sites. During the decade, Cuba started a policy of
supporting revolutionary movements throughout Latin America.
In
the 1970's Castro strengthened ties with the East Bloc. In 1972, five
years after he officially confirmed himself a Marxist-Leninist, Castro
signed a series of pacts with Eastern European governments - pledging
economic aid - while Cuba became a member of COMECON. Cuba's support
of rebellion world-wide continued during this decade. In 1975, Cuban
troops were sent into Angola to support the MPLA against the South African
-backed UNITA forces. United States - Cuba relations did improve during
this period - albeit very briefly.In
1977, U.S. President, Jimmy Carter, instituted a policy of reconciliation.
This involved the lifting of travel restrictions to Cuba on U.S. citizens,
the termination or reconnaissance missions by the U.S. government, the
establishment of interest sections in each nation's capital and the
conclusion of fishing agreements. But relations soon cooled once again.
The U.S. made it clear that in order for relations to be normalized,
Cuba had to pay compensation for American property seized by Castro,
apart from curbing its involvement in Africa. For the Cubans, negotiations
could only proceed further once the U.S. lifted the embargo. The Carter
administration then felt the backlash of a number of foreign policy
disasters. These included the overthrow of president Somoza in Nicaragua
by the Sandanistas and the capture of American hostages in Iran. Carter
was made to pay at the polls and he was defeated in the 1980 Presidential
elections by Ronald Reagan.
The
Reagan administration pursued an aggressive foreign policy from 1981
- 1989.
It became apparent that the opportunity for reconciliation with Cuba
had been lost and, in 1982, the travel-ban was reinstated. Castro soon
encountered many more problems. In 1983 the United States invaded Grenada
and forced the exile of Cuban construction workers and advisers - thus
ending Castro's relationship with the socialist government there. The
late 1980's saw a wave of global change as socialism went out in favour
of democratization. Between 1988 and 1990, the communist governments
of Eastern Europe ( Poland, Romania, Bulgaria, Czechoslovakia etc. )
fell one by one. Democracy also became the preference in Latin America
with military style regimes in Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Nicaragua
being superseded by popularly elected governments. By the early 1990's
Castro had lost his ideological support.
Ultimately,
the collapse of the U.S.S.R. in 1991 turned out to be an immense disaster
for Fidel Castro. The loss of trade subsidies, served to further cripple
the Cuban economy and to isolate the Castro government more than ever
before. The loss of Soviet imports and the burden of the soon-to-be strengthened
U.S. embargo would combine to make the 1990's a difficult period for Cuba.
This would lead to a situation, in which the Cuban leader would be forced
to make a number of domestic reforms in order to curb the effect of the
economic decline. It would also force a stand-off between Cuba and the
United States - a situation in which a peaceable solution has been thrown
in the balance.